Welcome to Elmhurst Famous Pizza
Elmhurst Famous Pizza, located in Jackson Heights, NY, is a cherished gem renowned for its fresh, personal pan pizzas. Each pie is crafted on-site, ensuring that patrons enjoy a hot, delicious experience, though patience is required as a 15-minute wait is typical. With highlights like the Grilled Chicken Cutlet Sandwich and Meatball Parmigiana Hero, their menu offers a variety of toasted heroes and hearty appetizers like mozzarella sticks and chicken wings. Customers rave about the authentic taste, claiming it embodies the true essence of New York pizza. Elmhurst Famous Pizza is not just a meal; it's a nostalgic experience waiting to be savored.
-
75-12 37th Ave, Jackson Heights, NY 11372, United States75-12 37th Ave, Jackson Heights, NY 11372, United States Hotline: +1 718-205-5000
Welcome to Elmhurst Famous Pizza, a beloved culinary gem nestled in the heart of Jackson Heights, New York. Conveniently located at 75-12 37th Avenue, this pizzeria has earned its reputation for serving up delicious, personal-sized pizzas that are crafted with precision and passion. Just a quick call to +1 718-205-5000 is all it takes to discover why locals and visitors alike sing its praises.
At Elmhurst Famous Pizza, the star of the show is undoubtedly the personal pan pizza, made fresh just for you. Each pie is the result of a perfect blend of ingredients, ensuring a symphony of flavors in every bite. Customers rave about the freshness and quality, with one review highlighting that the pizza is consistently “really good” and made to order. While it may require a brief wait, the payoff is well worth it—just be careful to let it cool, or you may find yourself with a scorched tongue!
But Elmhurst Famous Pizza isn't just about the pies. Their menu offers a diverse range of toasted heroes and wraps, perfect for those looking for a hearty meal. From the savory Eggplant Parmigiana Hero to the zesty Sausage Hero—featuring both hot and sweet sausage—there's something to tantalize every palate. Not to be overlooked are the appetizers, such as the crispy Jersey Shore French Fries and gooey Mozzarella Sticks, each designed to kick off your meal on a high note.
Customer experiences vary, with some emphasizing the no-frills attitude of the staff, who are simply focused on delivering delicious food as efficiently as possible. The ambiance has also received accolades for its recent makeover, making it a cozy spot to enjoy your meal amid the bustling neighborhood vibe.
Whether you’re a lifelong New Yorker or just passing through, Elmhurst Famous Pizza is a must-try. Each visit promises a flavorful journey through authentic pizza culture—a true representation of New York’s culinary scene. So why not pay a visit? Grab a personal pie, savor the rich flavors, and become part of the local pizza-loving community!
I grew up on this pizza as I had lived nearby. It's still one of my favorite pizza places if I happen to be in the neighborhood. They don't have slices here. All their pizzas are personal pan pies. When you order, they will make it fresh for you, which usually requires about a 15 minute wait, but it's totally worth it. I cannot emphasize this enough, but do not bite into it the second you get it, you will burn your mouth (happens to me everytime!). I highly recommend trying this place.
Haven’t been there in years. The place looks really cool now. Nice makeover. But the service sucks. Guy with an attitude, like you were asking for a freebie.
The personal pizza is really good made fresh every time
Brought my mom up for a quick day trip to NYC and we almost forgot to get her famous NY pizza. I googled this place as it wasn’t far from the airport and it certainly didn’t disappoint! We were absolutely full from eating all day but got a personal pie with pepperoni and sausage and it was outstanding! She certainly said it was the best pizza ever!
Soft ass NON-New Yorkers with their 1 stars hahaha... employees arent mean. They're just to the point, real Italian dudes. Just called and placed an order, guy was nice as ever. This place is a gem - the pizza is AMAZING.
The pizza pie is a 5-STAR! Definitely come to this place.
This is our go-to pizza place in our neighborhood and we can't say enough good things about it. The guys who work there are friendly and kind, the pizza is delicious, and the prices are reasonable (as are the portions). Our usuals are the hot pepper pizza (jalapeno) and salad - but the mozzarella sticks and garlic knots are also fantastic. We love this place and will continue to order from here regularly!
The food is really good. Their formula to make pizzas is different than other pizza stores and they have a unique taste that they've kept the whole time I've been coming to this store since 2010.